Tobias Myers competed twice at Cooperstown Dreams Park, both times with Team Avalanche (FL). His first trip was in 2009, Tournament 3; the team reached the Sweet 16. Tobias’s final play was Tournament 11 in 2011, reaching the Elite 8.

Tobias graduated from Winter Haven High School (Winter Haven, FL) and was a pitcher for the baseball team. During his senior year, he recorded an 8-2 record with a 1.51 ERA. He committed to play baseball at University of South Florida (Tampa, FL), however, he was selected by the Baltimore Orioles in the 2016 Major League Baseball draft and made the decision to go professional.

Tobias was traded to the Tampa Bay Rays on July 31, 2017. After four seasons, he was traded to the Cleveland Guardians in 2021 then the San Francisco Giants and Chicago White Sox in 2022. The Milwaukee Brewers picked up Tobias on November 22, 2022 and he made his Major League debut on August 23, 2024. He helped the Brewers clinch the 2025 National League Central division.

Following the 2025 season, Tobias was traded to the New York Mets.